Broken Arrow | South Tulsa | Brookside

Explore the Collections

The J. David Legacy Collection 5,600+ pieces Some things are meant to outlast us. The J. David Collection 2,600+ pieces Where your forever takes shape.

 

Gabriel & Co. 7,500+ styles The ring you’ve imagined, finished by hands you can trust. A.Jaffe 1,000+ pieces A promise made to last as long as yours.

By Category

Shown at our three Tulsa showrooms. View All Collections →

At the Bench

Jewelry Repair On our own benches, wherever it came from. Ring Resizing For the ring that almost fits. Appraisals The document your insurer accepts.

Also at J. David

Custom Design If you can dream it, we can make it. Gold Buying & Trade Somewhere in your house there is a box. The Watch Concierge The watch you have been looking for is out there.

More Services

Handled in our own workshops, never sent out. View All Services →
A jewelry box of gold bangles and pearl earrings, two gold bands beside it, one bracelet lifted out by hand
The Journal · Jewelry Care & Services

What Your Old Gold Is Actually Worth

Karat is a fraction, not a grade. Here is what that means for the chain that snapped, the single earring, and the ring nobody wears — and when a piece is worth more than the gold in it.

Somewhere in most houses there is a box. A chain that snapped and was never mended. One earring. A ring from a marriage, or from someone whose hands you still remember. None of it was thrown away, and that tells you something: it stopped being worn long before it stopped mattering.

It is still gold. It is still yours. And it is worth more than most people guess — sometimes as metal, sometimes as the piece it already is. Here is how we think about it, the way we would tell you with the box open between us.

Karat is a fraction, not a grade

Look inside the band of almost any ring and there is a small stamp. That number is a fraction out of 24. 14k is fourteen parts gold to ten parts other metals — about 58 percent gold. 18k is eighteen parts out of twenty-four, about 75 percent. 24k is pure gold, too soft for a ring meant to be lived in.

So 10k is not lesser gold and 24k is not better gold. They are different alloys made for different lives. A 10k ring is harder and forgives a working hand; an 18k ring is richer in color and gentler. For the question you came with, the stamp answers one thing only: how much of the piece is gold. How each karat wears on the hand is in Jewelry Metals: Gold, Platinum and the Rest.

Stamp Parts gold Roughly
10k 10 of 24 42% gold
14k 14 of 24 58% gold
18k 18 of 24 75% gold
22k 22 of 24 92% gold
24k 24 of 24 Pure gold

Weight and karat set the floor

Two things decide what gold is worth as metal: how much of it there is, and how pure it is. Everything after that is a conversation.

That is why a heavy 10k bracelet can be worth more than a fine 18k chain, and why nobody honest will give you a number over the phone. It is also why the shape it is in does not matter. Broken, bent, knotted, missing its partner — the gold is still the gold. What happened to the piece did not happen to the metal.

A pile of gold jewelry on a pocket scale
Weight and karat. Everything else is a conversation.

What is not gold

Not everything in the box belongs on the scale. Diamonds and colored gems are valued on their own, and sometimes they are the most valuable thing in the tray. Clasps, spring rings and earring backs are often a different metal entirely. So are the steel pins in a watch band and the workings inside a brooch.

None of that is a problem. It only means a box is rarely one thing, and the honest way through it is piece by piece, in a sorting tray, in front of you.

The gold from a box nobody opens turns into the thing somebody wears every day.

When a piece is worth more than its gold

This is the part worth slowing down for, because melting cannot be taken back.

Some pieces are worth more as themselves. A signed piece from a maker people collect. A setting from a time when hands made what machines now cannot. A diamond that would cost far more to buy than to reset. An engraving somebody meant, in handwriting you would know anywhere.

A buyer who is paying you for metal has every reason to stay quiet about this. We would rather say it. If the answer is this one, keep, then that is the answer, and it goes back in your hand instead of onto the scale.

A check, or something else

If what you want is money, that is a perfectly good reason to sell, and it is why most people come in. We pay by check, written while you wait.

But gold has a second door. Traded toward another piece rather than taken as a check, the same gold is worth more — at J. David, 50% more, and the credit does not expire. It can become a band, a pendant, or the metal in something drawn from nothing around a diamond you already own.

A gloved hand pouring old gold chains onto a jeweler's scale
Poured out, and gone through piece by piece.

That is the version where the story does not end. The gold from a box nobody opens turns into the thing somebody wears every day.

Bring the box to any of our three Tulsa showrooms and come sit with us. Looking at it costs nothing, and nothing is decided that you did not decide.

Good Questions

What does 14k gold actually mean?

Karat is a fraction out of 24. 14k gold is 14 parts gold to 10 parts other metals, or about 58 percent pure. 18k is 18 parts out of 24, about 75 percent. 24k is pure gold. The number is a statement of how much gold is in the alloy, not a grade of quality.

Is a broken piece of gold worth less than a whole one?

Not as metal. A snapped chain, a bent ring and a single earring carry exactly the gold they always did, and gold is valued by karat and weight. What a break can change is whether the piece is worth repairing instead — which is worth asking before anything is melted.

Is it better to sell gold or trade it?

It depends on whether you want money or something to wear. At J. David a trade credit is worth 50% more than the check we would write for the same gold, and that credit does not expire. If there is any chance the gold becomes another piece, trade is the better door.

The Inner Circle

First look, before anyone else.

New pieces as they land, the evenings we open the doors after hours, and now and then a story from the bench.

Or begin your ring →
Visit a Showroom

See it in person.

Three showrooms across Tulsa, one family since 1994. Bring your questions, or just come and look.

Verified on Google

In Their Own Words.

Every heirloom begins with a story. Hear from the families who let us be a part of theirs.

★★★★★ Trusted by Generations 5,300+ Five-Star Google Reviews
”

Katelyn helped me resize and refresh my wedding ring. She was knowledgeable, professional, and incredibly sweet. She made the experience easy and enjoyable, and I couldn’t be happier with the results. I highly recommend asking for Katelyn

★★★★★
Kim Coder
Broken Arrow · Google · Jul 2026
”

Had a fantastic experience at J David! Bought an engagement ring last year and a wedding band this year. Maelei and Susan were especially super helpful and patient with us and found us the perfect matches!

★★★★★
Matthew Thomas
South Tulsa · Google · Apr 2026
”

One big request I had for Hayley was to make sure any leftover gold from the ring was returned to me. Not only did she make sure I got the gold, but Scott even turned it into a small pendant!

★★★★★
Michael Reid
Brookside · Google · Aug 2026